Smoke a Joint, Lose Your Country

Tags: marijuana, aggravated, felony, carachuri, supreme, offenses, deportable, convicted, padilla, attorney

Under U.S. law, a legal resident who commits an "aggravated felony" is automatically deported. But a crime need not be aggravated or a felony to qualify: As several groups that defend immigrants' rights note in a recent Supreme Court brief, the category has been interpreted to include minor offenses such as selling a $10 bag of marijuana, selling counterfeit clothing, stealing a $10 video game, shoplifting baby clothes worth $15, forging a $20 check, and pulling another woman's hair in a fight over a boyfriend.

The immigration consequences of criminal convictions are especially disproportionate in drug cases, where suspicion of foreigners converges with fear of the intoxicants historically linked to them. As two recent Supreme Court cases illustrate, this combination can result in prolonged detention and lifelong banishment of people who have lived here for decades, separating them from their jobs, their families, and their communities, all for victimless crimes.

A noncitizen is deportable if he is convicted of any drug law violation except for "a single offense involving possession for one's own use of 30 grams [about an ounce] or less of marijuana." In a case the Supreme Court decided last week, a Kentucky truck driver named Jose Padilla (not to be confused with the American citizen convicted of assisting terrorism) pleaded guilty to transporting marijuana. Padilla, a Vietnam War veteran from Honduras, did not realize the plea meant he would have to leave the country he had called home for more than 40 years. Because his attorney wrongly assured him he would not be deported, the Court ruled that Padilla had been deprived of his Sixth Amendment right to "the effective assistance of competent counsel."

On the same day it announced that decision, the Court heard a case involving a Mexican immigrant, Jose Angel Carachuri-Rosendo, who became a legal U.S. resident in 1993 and more than a decade later served a 20-day sentence in a Texas jail for misdemeanor marijuana possession. The following year, he was caught with one tablet of Xanax, for which he served 10 days in jail.

According to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit, these two trivial offenses added up to an "aggravated felony," which not only made Carachuri deportable but barred him from asking the attorney general for a "cancellation of removal." The 5th Circuit's reasoning, which has been endorsed by one other federal appeals court and rejected by four, goes like this: Although Carachuri was never convicted of a felony, he theoretically could have been charged as a recidivist under federal law, which would have made him eligible for a sentence of 15 days to two years.

Another victim of such imaginary charges is Jerry Lemaine, a 28-year-old New Yorker who was born in Haiti but has lived in this country since he was 3. Caught with a joint on Long Island in 2007, Lemaine pleaded guilty and paid a $100 fine, only to be shipped off to Texas by immigration authorities. They detained him there for three years after determining that he, like Carachuri, qualified as an "aggravated felon" in the 5th Circuit (though not in the 2nd Circuit, where he was cited for the marijuana).

Lemaine, you see, had also been charged with possessing a small amount of marijuana as a teenager. Although the charge was ultimately dismissed, in the federal government's view it still made him a recidivist, which made him an aggravated felon, which made him deportable without recourse for drug violations that in New York do not even qualify as criminal offenses.

Outrages like this occur largely because Congress in 1996 eliminated judges' discretion to prevent deportation of people who do not deserve it and severely restricted the attorney general's authority to do so. Like mandatory minimum sentences, these changes were aimed at reining in misguided compassion and eliminating inappropriate disparities. And like mandatory minimums, rigid deportation rules have resulted in a different sort of injustice. Tougher is not always better.

Jacob Sullum is a senior editor at Reason and a nationally syndicated columnist. This column first appeared at

© Copyright 2010 by Creators Syndicate Inc.

Not yet rated. Be the first:

<< Previous Article      Next Article >>



Kim said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Gnome de Plume wrote:Now I am home, too. I had a panic attack for ahiwle. Could NOT find my car key. It is one of those with the computer chip in it that locks and alarms the car. The car was locked and alarmed – not something I do at home – so I knew that the button had to have been pushed accidentally, which sometimes happens when it is in my pocket and I lean up against something. But all my pockets were empty! Maybe the key was in the car – I remember working with stuff in the back of it. Maybe I laid the key down, or it fell out? But I couldn’t see it in the car. Talked to the dealer. Because the car was alarmed, the only way to get it straightened out and to get it re-keyed would be to tow it to the Volvo dealer in either San Antonio or Austin!But then, as I was calling my parents to see if I could borrow a car from them, I happened to flip up the sofa cushions. There in the crack, with three dog bones and a dish towel and a ton of dirt was my key! It must have fallen out of my pocket when I sat down to watch some football and then one of my wee, little puppies mast have stood on it with his dainty paw and pushed the contraption down in the crack while setting the alarm button!Whew! Almost a catastrophe. So I just now finished my errands. Mr. Gnome got home just now, too. He is once again cleaning the kitchen prior to my cooking. All keyed up and no where to go? Hey, you get a clean kitchen to start with, what's wrong with that?

8/22/2012 8:19:10 PM 

buy viagra said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

IfU0ro wow, awesome blog.Really looking forward to read more. Much obliged.

1/9/2013 11:03:45 PM 

dofollow social bookmarking sites said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

SbUOQL Thanks-a-mundo for the article post.Much thanks again. Really Great.

1/18/2013 12:52:02 AM 

lose weight naturally said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Very good article.Much thanks again. Fantastic.

1/19/2013 5:20:57 AM 

buy generic cialis said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

v5jQ3z Great, thanks for sharing this article post.Thanks Again. Really Great.

1/27/2013 2:36:42 AM 

buy discount viagra said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

2c5E77 Very neat article post.Really thank you! Awesome.

2/2/2013 10:05:29 PM 

buy stendra generic said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

EbqVRL Major thankies for the blog article.Much thanks again.

2/14/2013 6:25:10 PM 

buy stendra said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

caf7PB Really enjoyed this blog article.Really thank you! Really Cool.

2/23/2013 6:16:31 PM 

clomid no prescription said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Very informative blog post.Thanks Again. Much obliged.

2/25/2013 7:34:17 AM 

bookmaring service said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

fmHblV Fantastic blog.Really looking forward to read more. Great.

3/13/2013 12:24:19 PM 

bookmarks said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Xf57hF Awesome blog article.Much thanks again. Want more.

3/14/2013 12:30:31 PM 

what is ciprofloxacin said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

I really liked your blog article.Really thank you! Fantastic.

3/15/2013 9:43:01 AM 

generic viagra without a prescription said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

I loved your article post.Really looking forward to read more. Really Great.

3/15/2013 11:21:16 AM 

Buy Levitra said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Major thankies for the blog article.Thanks Again. Cool.

3/15/2013 2:39:59 PM 

buy generic cialis said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Thanks-a-mundo for the article.Thanks Again. Much obliged.

3/15/2013 1:00:31 PM