Collars for Dollars



Tags: police, arrests, overtime, officer, baltimore, arrest, public, marijuana, people, officers

When I was a police officer in Baltimore, one sergeant would sometimes motivate his troops in the middle of a shift change by joyfully shouting, “All right, you maggots! Let’s lock people up! They don’t pay you to stand around. I want production! I want lockups!” He said this while standing in front of a small sign he most likely authored: “Unlike the citizens of the Eastern District, you are required to work for your government check.”

In the police world, there are good arrests and better arrests, but there is no such thing as a bad arrest. In recent years, measures of “productivity” have achieved an almost totemic significance. And because they are so easy to count, arrests have come to outweigh more important but harder-to-quantify variables such as crimes prevented, fights mitigated, or public fears assuaged.

There’s an argument that putting pressure on rank-and-file officers to make lots of arrests is a good thing. After all, we pay police to arrest criminals. But there’s a difference between quantity and quality. Quantity is easy to influence, and the rank and file can easily increase their output of discretionary arrests for minor offenses like loitering, disorderly conduct, and possession of marijuana. They are also influenced by what is known in New York as “collars for dollars”: Arrest numbers are influenced by the incentive of overtime pay for finishing up paperwork and appearing in court.

Police would love to arrest only “real” criminals, but that isn’t easy. It’s difficult to find a good criminal. There’s never a felon around when you need one. Fishing for low-level drug arrests is a far easier way to generate overtime.

When I worked in Baltimore, officers would pull up on a drug corner and stop the slowest addict walking away. While conducting a perfectly legal “Terry Frisk”—a cursory search nominally conducted for officer safety—cops would feel some drugs in a pocket. That easy arrest and lockup likely meant two hours of overtime pay.

In some cities, like New York, it’s trickier. Overtime for court testimony is harder to get, and the state’s highest court has ruled—precisely to prevent the Baltimore-style approach—that feeling drugs during a Terry Frisk does not allow an officer to search that pocket and remove those drugs. The court reasoned that the drugs are not a threat to the officer’s safety, and safety is the only justification for these sorts of frisks.

In New York state, small-scale possession of marijuana is virtually decriminalized. It’s not even an arrestable offense. But police in need of overtime are nothing if not wily. So a group of officers might approach a man in a high-crime neighborhood and, in no uncertain terms, “ask” him to empty his pockets. Fearful, resigned, or simply taking the path of least resistance, the suspect might do so, and in the process he might reveal a small “dime bag” of weed. While possessing that amount of marijuana is not an arrestable offense, it becomes one as soon as the drug is placed in “public view.”

Supporters sometimes say these small-scale drug arrests are part of a “broken windows” approach to preventing crime. This tactic comes from an influential 1982 Atlantic magazine article by George Kelling and James Q. Wilson that combined the 19th century police theories of Robert Peel with the 20th century urban philosophy of Jane Jacobs. The idea is that if you take care of the little things—disorder, quality-of-life issues, and public fear—then the big things like robbery and murder will take care of themselves.

Since Police Commissioner William Bratton implemented a broken windows policing strategy in the early 1990s, homicides in New York dropped more than 80 percent. But the crime didn’t drop because police were cracking down on drug users; overall, illegal drug use is as high as ever. When the murder rate was falling fastest in the 1990s, police never arrested more than a few thousand people per year for public-view marijuana. Only after the crime drop slowed did police turn to small-scale drug arrests to meet their “productivity goals.” It’s as if real criminals became too difficult to find, and the addiction to overtime pay remained strong as ever.

Last year in New York City, 50,300 people—mostly young black and Hispanic men—were arrested solely for misdemeanor “public-view” possession of marijuana. It’s true that some may have been up to no good. And some might have been walking down the street proudly smoking a spliff in front of the police. But nobody really believes this accounts for most of those 50,300 lockups. Many were people just going about their business, intending to smoke later, in private, in the very manner the law was intended to decriminalize.

“What is it with the drugs?” a man once asked me while I was policing a 7-11 for coffee, “When there’s shootin’ or fightin’, you don’t seem to care! But when there’s drugs, you come right away.” It’s a fair question to ask. Why do we do it? What do we gain? Especially when we know drug arrests are expensive and turn a lot of otherwise law-abiding citizens into cop-hating criminals?

The drug war, because it can’t be won, encourages outward signs of police effectiveness at the expense of good old-fashioned policing. Hard-working cops, especially those who ask for little more than a middle-class income in return for the dangerous work they do, turn to drug arrests to make ends meet. The Baltimore sergeant was right: Police officers do need to work for their government check. It’s a shame “collars for dollars” has become the easiest way to do it. 

Peter Moskos (moskos@gmail.com), a former Baltimore police officer, is an assistant professor of law and political science at John Jay College of Criminal Justice, The City University of New York's Doctoral Program in Sociology, and LaGuardia Community College's Department of Social Science. He is the author of In Defense of Flogging (2011) and Cop in the Hood: My Year Policing Baltimore's Eastern District (2008). This column first appeared at Reason.com.

Not yet rated. Be the first:

<< Previous Article      Next Article >>


Comment

Name:

Marco said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

That's also a reporter who has cevored the cops too much: Police canine sheesh. I know wading through cop press releases can turn brains to mush, but this paper is on the slippy slope of printing a story with perps in the lede.

8/23/2012 1:41:35 AM 

http://1buyviagrahere.com/ said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

TqLLwC Thanks so much for the post.Much thanks again. Much obliged.

12/23/2012 10:05:31 AM 

best tips to lose weight said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

I truly appreciate this article post.Thanks Again. Keep writing.

12/29/2012 5:25:57 PM 

diet and weight loss said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

I loved your article. Much obliged.

12/29/2012 5:25:58 PM 

Easy Video Suite Review said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

I really enjoy the blog article.Thanks Again. Want more.

1/11/2013 6:53:46 AM 

property marketing london|cgi company london|architectural visualisations london|cgi design|property marketing agencies said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Really informative blog article.Much thanks again. Will read on...

1/10/2013 3:18:08 PM 

does inteligator work said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Thanks again for the blog article.Really thank you! Will read on...

1/11/2013 8:51:04 AM 

lingam massage said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

wow, awesome blog post.Really thank you! Really Great.

1/11/2013 10:49:59 AM 

Website Promotion said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Enjoyed every bit of your post.Much thanks again. Fantastic.

1/11/2013 12:47:08 PM 

domain marketplace said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

I loved your article. Want more.

1/11/2013 2:43:28 PM 

Buy Local Experts said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

wow, awesome blog post. Keep writing.

1/11/2013 4:39:17 PM 

Twin peak profits said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Really appreciate you sharing this blog article.Much thanks again. Great.

1/12/2013 7:50:19 AM 

vpn said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Wow, great post.Really thank you! Keep writing.

1/11/2013 6:37:20 PM 

poker table rental toronto said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

A big thank you for your blog post.Thanks Again. Really Cool.

1/11/2013 8:33:42 PM 

chatrandom camzap said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

A big thank you for your article post.Much thanks again. Great.

1/12/2013 10:20:21 AM 

buy viagra said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Muchos Gracias for your blog post.

1/14/2013 8:24:14 AM 

pijat tradisional said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Great article.Really thank you! Want more.

1/11/2013 10:29:45 PM 

viagra 50mg said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Thanks for sharing, this is a fantastic blog.Thanks Again. Great.

1/14/2013 4:17:34 AM 

work online from home said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Great, thanks for sharing this post.

1/15/2013 6:02:59 AM 

die cutting said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Really enjoyed this blog article. Want more.

1/12/2013 12:26:53 AM 

Blutdruck Senken said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Great, thanks for sharing this blog article.Much thanks again. Much obliged.

1/14/2013 1:27:57 PM 

Chicago chiropractic said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Looking forward to reading more. Great blog post.Much thanks again. Cool.

1/14/2013 9:23:42 AM 

free joomla plugins said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Thank you for your article post.Really thank you! Awesome.

1/14/2013 5:28:54 AM 

comprare cialis said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

wow, awesome blog article.Much thanks again. Will read on...

1/14/2013 5:32:27 AM 

buy cialis said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Looking forward to reading more. Great article.Really thank you! Much obliged.

1/14/2013 9:44:03 AM 

CREAZIONE SITI FROSINONE said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Really appreciate you sharing this post.Really thank you!

1/12/2013 2:20:27 AM 

Chauvet said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

I really enjoy the article post.Thanks Again. Will read on...

1/14/2013 8:44:12 PM 

Go Here said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Say, you got a nice post.Really thank you! Great.

1/15/2013 7:19:12 AM 

wordpress training said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Thanks so much for the post.Much thanks again. Great.

1/12/2013 6:44:42 AM 

granuflo lawsuit said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

I really enjoy the article. Awesome.

1/15/2013 7:43:27 AM 

seo services said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Muchos Gracias for your article.Really thank you! Awesome.

1/15/2013 11:39:52 AM 

How To Eat More to Lose More said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Really informative article post.Really thank you! Really Cool.

1/14/2013 11:25:43 AM 

Can I make Money Online said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Great, thanks for sharing this blog. Cool.

1/15/2013 12:16:15 PM 

goggles said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

I appreciate you sharing this article.

1/15/2013 5:30:40 PM 

greita paskola said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Thanks-a-mundo for the blog. Will read on...

1/15/2013 8:35:40 AM 

replica online store said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Great, thanks for sharing this blog article.Really thank you! Want more.

1/15/2013 7:22:28 PM 

Fantasy Book Author fan page said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

I really liked your article post. Great.

1/15/2013 9:42:26 AM 

Blutdruck Senken said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

I value the blog post.Much thanks again. Will read on...

1/16/2013 2:36:52 AM 

friv games said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

wow, awesome article post.Much thanks again. Really Cool.

1/15/2013 9:49:50 AM 

http://www.pharmacie-cialis.com/ said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Great blog.

1/14/2013 11:51:41 AM 

viagra en ligne said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Great blog.Much thanks again. Cool.

1/14/2013 6:56:20 AM 

USANA Health Sciences said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

I loved your blog.Thanks Again. Much obliged.

1/15/2013 1:28:38 PM 

Blutdruck Senken said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Im obliged for the blog article.Really thank you! Awesome.

1/14/2013 7:25:38 AM 

fastrack aviator sunglasses said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

I really like and appreciate your article.Really thank you! Much obliged.

1/15/2013 1:36:32 PM 

trendy clothes for women said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Great blog article. Really Great.

1/16/2013 9:45:42 AM 

Detektei said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

I really liked your blog.Much thanks again. Want more.

1/15/2013 2:41:14 PM 

Productos para Manualidades said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

I loved your blog post.Much thanks again. Awesome.

1/16/2013 10:22:39 AM 

Castleville Trainer said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Very neat blog article.Really thank you! Really Great.

1/16/2013 3:40:01 PM 

this site said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Very neat post.Much thanks again. Cool.

1/16/2013 3:32:35 AM 

sunglasses shop said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Thank you for your article post. Will read on...

1/15/2013 3:35:50 PM 

Event directory said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Im thankful for the blog article. Cool.

1/16/2013 4:57:09 AM 

Ipad said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Really appreciate you sharing this post.Really thank you! Really Great.

1/15/2013 11:03:39 AM 

download pdf said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

I really liked your blog article.Really thank you! Will read on...

1/14/2013 1:07:37 PM 

blocked drain brisbane said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

I value the blog.Thanks Again. Want more.

1/15/2013 3:52:57 PM 

car insurance said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

I loved your blog post.Thanks Again. Great.

1/17/2013 7:47:56 AM 

Bal der Bals said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Thanks again for the article post.Thanks Again. Great.

1/17/2013 9:00:08 PM 

petaluma iphone 3GS repair said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Thanks for the article post.Really looking forward to read more. Fantastic.

1/16/2013 10:59:20 AM 

The Diet solution program PDF said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

A round of applause for your article post.Really thank you! Great.

1/16/2013 12:12:36 PM 

angel fischen said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

I really like and appreciate your blog article.Much thanks again. Much obliged.

1/17/2013 10:54:45 PM 

cake sydney said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

A big thank you for your post.Really looking forward to read more. Want more.

1/16/2013 3:47:01 AM 

Ange Kagame photos said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

I truly appreciate this post.Much thanks again. Really Cool.

1/18/2013 12:49:16 AM 

lidafarmedli lida said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

I appreciate you sharing this article.Thanks Again.

1/17/2013 9:39:41 AM 

buy twitter followers said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

I appreciate you sharing this article.Really looking forward to read more. Really Great.

1/17/2013 1:25:09 PM 

buy real facebook likes said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

I think this is a real great blog article. Cool.

1/16/2013 12:17:00 PM 

OMG Machines Bonus said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Thanks so much for the blog article.Really thank you! Really Cool.

1/18/2013 5:34:21 AM 

World News said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Great, thanks for sharing this blog post.Much thanks again. Will read on...

1/17/2013 1:42:15 PM 

tasaciones de fincas said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Major thanks for the article.Much thanks again. Keep writing.

1/18/2013 5:37:53 AM 

application said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Im thankful for the article post.Thanks Again. Fantastic.

1/15/2013 3:29:59 AM 

residential locksmith houston said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Fantastic blog.Much thanks again. Keep writing.

1/18/2013 3:08:47 AM 

chauvet disco light said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Very neat blog post.Thanks Again. Fantastic.

1/15/2013 3:41:49 AM 

Best coffee makers said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Really appreciate you sharing this article.Really looking forward to read more. Cool.

1/17/2013 11:15:26 AM 

choirs in edinburgh said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Thanks-a-mundo for the blog article.Really looking forward to read more. Awesome.

1/18/2013 3:39:42 AM 

vacaciones said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

A round of applause for your post.

1/16/2013 1:23:45 PM 

what is business said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

I value the blog article.Really thank you! Really Cool.

1/17/2013 11:32:14 AM 

optin form design said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Enjoyed every bit of your blog post.Much thanks again. Really Cool.

1/18/2013 6:47:08 AM 

misoprostol price said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

I cannot thank you enough for the article.Much thanks again. Keep writing.

1/17/2013 2:52:47 PM 

dance plus Lessons Tulsa Weekly Tuesday Moose said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Major thankies for the article.Much thanks again. Much obliged.

1/15/2013 4:45:54 AM 

diet plan said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Im obliged for the article post.Really looking forward to read more. Great.

1/18/2013 4:22:09 AM 

Boise web design said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Im thankful for the article.Thanks Again. Much obliged.

1/16/2013 2:31:48 PM 

quickquid said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Thanks so much for the post.

1/17/2013 3:18:56 PM 

best hair straighteners said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Great, thanks for sharing this blog article.Really looking forward to read more.

1/17/2013 12:31:12 PM 

easy jobs that pay well said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

A round of applause for your article post.Really looking forward to read more. Keep writing.

1/18/2013 7:37:24 AM 

android said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Really enjoyed this blog post.Thanks Again. Will read on...

1/17/2013 5:13:05 PM 

click here said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Thanks for the article post.Thanks Again.

1/18/2013 9:34:36 AM 

agentie de turism said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Really informative blog post.Much thanks again. Much obliged.

1/18/2013 8:00:00 AM 

CASH FOR PHONES said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

I appreciate you sharing this article.Really thank you! Will read on...

1/18/2013 2:37:18 PM 

Kosmetikerin said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Wow, great blog article.Thanks Again. Cool.

1/17/2013 7:05:38 PM 

Bal du Zoute said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

I really like and appreciate your blog post. Really Great.

1/18/2013 9:18:28 AM 

surf hostal tarifa said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Really appreciate you sharing this article.Thanks Again. Really Cool.

1/18/2013 10:39:23 AM 

book said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Thanks again for the blog post. Want more.

1/20/2013 2:05:15 AM 

MMA Training Houston said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

A big thank you for your blog article. Fantastic.

1/18/2013 3:22:45 PM 

how to create an app said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Thanks so much for the blog article.Really thank you! Cool.

1/15/2013 5:42:58 AM 

how to make a website said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Very good blog.Really thank you! Will read on...

1/18/2013 11:29:56 AM 

best furnace cleaning Calgary said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

I cannot thank you enough for the article post.Much thanks again. Awesome.

1/18/2013 3:49:43 PM 

How much is my website worth said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Major thanks for the blog article.Much thanks again. Really Cool.

1/21/2013 4:40:58 AM 

orgone said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

I really liked your blog. Fantastic.

1/18/2013 12:02:13 PM 

Buy Instagram followers said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Im thankful for the blog article.Really thank you!

1/22/2013 2:25:27 AM 

canada printing said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Thanks so much for the post. Cool.

1/18/2013 5:19:53 PM 

shopping center investments said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Im thankful for the blog.Much thanks again. Really Great.

1/24/2013 1:25:40 AM 

Google Sniper 2.0 Bonus said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Thank you for your article.Really thank you! Want more.

1/18/2013 1:22:32 PM 

SEM said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Awesome blog post. Will read on...

1/18/2013 1:25:11 PM 

Farmville 2 Hack Download said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

I cannot thank you enough for the article.Really looking forward to read more.

1/25/2013 5:56:47 AM 

pajama kids said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Thanks for the article.Much thanks again. Will read on...

1/25/2013 7:14:56 AM 

Make money from home said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Really enjoyed this article post.Much thanks again. Much obliged.

1/29/2013 9:02:03 PM 

anonymous said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Really enjoyed this article.Thanks Again. Want more.

1/30/2013 8:01:14 PM 

payday loans said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Wow, great article post.Really thank you! Really Great.

1/28/2013 6:09:09 AM 

Web Design said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Very neat blog post.Really looking forward to read more. Much obliged.

1/31/2013 2:23:30 AM 

chatrandom said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

I cannot thank you enough for the blog.Really looking forward to read more. Fantastic.

1/29/2013 9:16:42 AM 

credit repair said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Thanks again for the blog.Much thanks again. Will read on...

1/31/2013 3:46:43 AM 

Payday loans said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

I really enjoy the article post.Really thank you! Will read on...

1/29/2013 10:48:35 AM 

best weight loss said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

I really liked your post.Thanks Again. Really Great.

1/29/2013 12:23:20 PM 

candy store said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Hey, thanks for the post.Really thank you! Will read on...

1/16/2013 6:07:11 AM 

bluehost coupon 2013 said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

I cannot thank you enough for the article post.

1/16/2013 6:33:15 AM 

Buy Neopoints said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

A big thank you for your post. Will read on...

1/16/2013 7:19:22 AM 

Super hero t-shirts said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

I value the blog article.Thanks Again. Much obliged.

1/16/2013 8:27:01 AM 

desktop wallpapers said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Thanks-a-mundo for the blog.Thanks Again. Much obliged.

2/6/2013 3:11:24 AM 

wedding videography melbourne said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Muchos Gracias for your article.Really looking forward to read more. Much obliged.

1/16/2013 8:31:59 AM 

fwresh hair design said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Major thankies for the article post. Much obliged.

1/17/2013 2:59:20 AM 

kim kardashian sex tape said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

A round of applause for your post.Really thank you! Fantastic.

1/17/2013 4:00:54 AM 

Exercise Motivation said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Thank you ever so for you article.Really looking forward to read more. Awesome.

1/17/2013 4:08:41 AM 

commercial locksmith houston said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

A round of applause for your blog article.Really thank you! Keep writing.

1/17/2013 5:19:41 AM 

Motivasi Kerja said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Really appreciate you sharing this post. Want more.

1/17/2013 5:54:42 AM 

bad service said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

Really enjoyed this article post.Thanks Again. Will read on...

2/28/2013 11:28:50 AM 

Cash loan|Bridging loan said... Rating: 0   Vote +   Vote -  

I truly appreciate this post.Really thank you! Much obliged.

3/8/2013 2:42:14 AM